Brady>Manning
- Thread starter Senek8
- Start date
STLCoach
Nobiscum Deus
Super Bowl wins doesn't translate to QB success.. If that were true.. Bob Greise would be considered better than Manning.. Which everyone in the world and probably Mars too knows that he's not.
Last edited:
utcw201
☼☼☼☼☼☼☼☼☼
What class are you in tonight snuffleupagus??
STLCoach
Nobiscum Deus
History of internet douchebags.. We're going over your profile now. :thumb:
utcw201
☼☼☼☼☼☼☼☼☼
such a christian thing to say...piece of cake be with you
STLCoach
Nobiscum Deus
Hey.. You give, You get. You're not interested in anything I have to say anyway. I may have a piece of cake, You however need a big slice of humble pie.
BrandoMartino23
the dude
They both better than anything the jets have had in the last 20 years...****, just watching Wilson last night was enough to make me cry.
Senek8
Addicted to Softballfans
No, it doesn't, but being a relevant contender every season you have been in the league, most of which have been with a mediocre supporting cast and no running game does. Peryton looked like he was doing the Irish jig in the pocket last night, made some extremely poor decisions trying to force passes that weren't meant to be thrown and ultimately couldn't figure out a way to get his team into a rhythm is enough to say that he just doesn't have the ability to get it done when he needs to, and Brady has delivered on more than one occasion. The one year Brady had a great receiving core, he set the single season TD record, which was broken by Peyton this year...
swingnmiss
#1 IN YOUR HEARTS
I would take Brady in this too. All things considered and being "relatively" equal, winning is the difference maker. They've each had outstanding careers, set records and won a lot of games. Manning has the edge in some catgories, but he's been in the league longer, but those 5 appearences and 3 wins?? That does it for me.
LngBallLvr
Addicted to Softballfans
Peyton would have won easily if he played for Seattle.
STLCoach
Nobiscum Deus
He was facing the best defense in the league the other night. Their linebackers, corners, and safety are probably some of the best I've ever seen. They were playing tight coverage. Peyton, "in all honesty" had a horrific game and still threw for 280 with a passer rating that game of 73.5 meaning he was still better than most existing QB's in the NFL at his absolute worst.
I really don't know how I could be reading posts and sports writers saying that Peyton isn't a "big game" QB.. That's complete non-sense because he's already won a ring in which he did it against a good defense. Not nearly as good as the Seattle defense but good nonetheless. I'm sure they'll be right back in it next season just the same.. If they can keep that offense together, healthy, and beef up the defense? Shoot.. they may go all the way next season.
Marshenko
Well-Known Member
Peyton threw for more INTs during the Colts Super Bowl winning playoff run than the previous 5 and following 5 Super Bowl winning QBs combined. He had 3 TDs and 7 INTs. Lets not go nuts over 2006 - the Colts defense, though terrible in the regular season, played out of their minds during that run.
rossthefireman
mexicola
Does everyone seem to forget that the only Super Bowl Peyton has won was against a Rex Grossman led Bears? Let that sink in for a sec. He beat Rex ****ing Grossman........
rossthefireman
mexicola
I swear from the first play on Peyton had that 'oh god they are going to hurt me' look on his face all night.
Eli > Peyton in big games.
Eli > Peyton in big games.
rossthefireman
mexicola
Its a good way to live though. Those people seem to have the most fun.
hrdchrgin13
Well-Known Member
He don't even know whats going on
