I sell balls that are pretty well used to my local pias for $1.50 ea, I've sold very good/great condition $2.50/$2.75ish ea
Back when i started selling to them they were at .50/.75cent till i pointed out to the owner that every ball i sold him were in much better shape than anything else he had in his baskets. He sells them for $3 eaThat's insane. Here, you get 50 cents per ball at PIAS, and they sell them for $1.50. I could get rich if I sold every used softball I found for $1.50.