Baseball Keepers: Pick 5

[The Crimedog]

Rules:
1- You must keep 1-IF, 1-OF, 1P, 2- Anyone
2- You lose the round they're kept in
3- This is my last year to keep Trout
4- I lost in the championship so I get the 11th pick.


Stanton R2
Trout R20
Goldschmidt R5
Adam Jones R3
Altuve R7
Victor Martinez R13
Machado R23

Jordan Zimmerman R4
Jacob DeGrom Last Round
Julio Teheran R21 (Don't be fooled by his W-L his ERA was 2.89
Masahiro Tanaka R8
Yordano Ventura Last Round


I think I'm looking at

Stanton
Trout
Altuve
Martinez
Teheran

Everyone else I'll be able to redraft possibly. Tanaka is a strong possibility too.

 

[j.bishop]

Stanton
Trout
Goldschmidt
Teheran
deGroom or Ventura

 

[T.Heck]

Altuve
Ventura
Trout
Stanton
Goldschmidt

Draft pitching

 

[j.bishop]

You just don't like Teheran Mr.Heck, round 21 value can't be passed up

 

[T.Heck]

I cant pass up those bats..... I love Teheran but somebody had to be left out. Ventura had same Ks in like 50 innings less I think

 

[BAplaya11]

I cant pass up those bats..... I love Teheran but somebody had to be left out. Ventura had same Ks in like 50 innings less I think

i agree with theck here too many good hitters. Im not touching Ventura that arm/elbow is going to explode soon. I would make the argument that DeGrom is a better value than Tehran.

 

[T.Heck]

DeGrom is interesting for sure.... I haven't seen him much but the numbers look good.

 

[The Crimedog]

i agree with theck here too many good hitters. Im not touching Ventura that arm/elbow is going to explode soon. I would make the argument that DeGrom is a better value than Tehran.

This is my problem, the hitting I had was deep. I should be able to redraft DeGrom and ventura if I chose to.

 

[j-sig]

Switch Martinez with Goldschmidt. Martinez just came off his career best year in his 30s and he just had knee surgery.

Degrom vs Teheran is personal preference IMO. Both pretty close to each other.

 

[STOMPKIN]

Take Teheran over Ventura, I think Ventura gets a serious injury this year.

 

[bobber_1077]

I have a hard time not taking these 4...
Stanton R2
Trout R20
Goldschmidt R5
Adam Jones R3

Then any one of Teheran, deGrom and Ventura...
Teheran I feel may be the safest, but he plays on the worst team of the 3.