Do yourself a favor here - Dont listen to NYC!!!!!!
He is showing you gloves that...
1) Are not even his gloves
2) Are unused
Why he would give you terrible advice, I do not know.
Why he wouldnt stop to consider you would be using your glove rather than put it on a shelf for 20 yrs... i do not know.
General rule of thumb, always get a 2nd opinion when considering adhering to his advice
Case in point.
i had a custom HOH that was red blue and camel.
it looked nice when new, but after only one season of use it went to poop.
The red turned pinkish (although not as bad as my old Pujols) and the blue just faded and it started getting much whiter.
If you want an excellent example of what the blue does with a lot of use here is Eric Hosmer's.
Keep in mind this is with a TON of use, but you get the idea.
looks a bit different than those 2 nice blue gloves above huh?
Keep in mind this is an extreme case. If you are getting a new glove next year like i did - then you have no reason to worry.
Use it, let it fade, move on.
If you are using it for a few years and things like that bother you - stick with something that isnt red/blue/green/orange etc
Good luck and let us know what you decide!!!