Keeper help

[bis25]

Need to choose between Desmond Jennings and Asdrubal Cabrera.

Already keeping: Pujols, Justin Upton, Mike Stanton, Roy Halladay

Drafting 10th and most likely going after a SP first (Lee, CC, Cain, Greinke, Weaver, Price are all available)

SS available to draft are: Reyes, Rollins, Alexi Ramirez, Jeter, Peralta, Hardy
OF available are: Hamilton, Cruz, Gordon, Crawford, Bourn, Werth, BJ Upton

Figuring on taking a hitter on the way back at 15. McCann, Utley, Weeks, Phillips, Arod, Youk, Pablo Sandoval are all also available at positions I need.

Basic 6x6 league, specialized OF positions (LF, CF, RF, OF)

Whos the better keeper?

 

[BAplaya11]

id keep jennings, higher upside. Also at 10 id be going after Reyes over a pitcher, hitting>pitching

 

[bis25]

id keep jennings, higher upside. Also at 10 id be going after Reyes over a pitcher, hitting>pitching

I have a feeling that Reyes will be long gone before 10. Based on what it looks like now, only 4 teams need pitchers in the first round. I usually take best available, which might be a SP

 

[tattt3]

Jennings as well......and go Cruz or Hamilton but im a Ranger homer haha...then go SP at 15

 

[Madbeers]

Asdrubal blows. 70% of his HR barely cleared the fences according to hit tracker. His numbers tanked as the season wore on. I would go Jennings but only if I had to. And if you can't get Reyes, then wait on SS. Bank on other positions and snag a guy like Dee Gordon or even Emilo Bonifacio. I would go Hamilton, Bourn, Cruz in that order. On the turn I would go.... Weeks, Phillips.

 

[Gallops]

Keep Jennings, wait on pitching. Pitching is the deepest position in fantasy baseball, and you can always trade one good hitter for 2 good pitchers. If Reyes isn't there at 10, go with Crawford or Arod.

 

[The Crimedog]

Need to choose between Desmond Jennings and Asdrubal Cabrera.

Already keeping: Pujols, Justin Upton, Mike Stanton, Roy Halladay

Drafting 10th and most likely going after a SP first (Lee, CC, Cain, Greinke, Weaver, Price are all available)

SS available to draft are: Reyes, Rollins, Alexi Ramirez, Jeter, Peralta, Hardy
OF available are: Hamilton, Cruz, Gordon, Crawford, Bourn, Werth, BJ Upton

Figuring on taking a hitter on the way back at 15. McCann, Utley, Weeks, Phillips, Arod, Youk, Pablo Sandoval are all also available at positions I need.

Basic 6x6 league, specialized OF positions (LF, CF, RF, OF)

Whos the better keeper?

Upside says keep Jennings especially if it's only costing you a last round pick (like he should be). Cabrerra has had this season ONCE. I like the guy but I don't love him.

 

[The Crimedog]

Asdrubal blows. 70% of his HR barely cleared the fences according to hit tracker. His numbers tanked as the season wore on. I would go Jennings but only if I had to. And if you can't get Reyes, then wait on SS. Bank on other positions and snag a guy like Dee Gordon or even Emilo Bonifacio. I would go Hamilton, Bourn, Cruz in that order. On the turn I would go.... Weeks, Phillips.

So if 70% of his HR's hit the wall, he still batted pretty well and drove in runs. He does not "blow" but he won't hit that many HR's again.