Lot of truth in this thread.
When I 1st got back into gloves I found out my go to 1b pattern was out of production for the 1st time in yrs.Its since come back, but all I could find new was a AP5. Same as the CMHC, just with a red web as most of you know. The more I looked into it after I got it, the more I started finding pictures of my beautiful cardinal red and black glove that had turned pink and black. Even after the 1st lexol application my sponge was now red and I could was ready see the change happening before my eyes so I got out of it as my OCD would have gone through the roof.
This spring I made a red/navy/camel custom cmhc. Red Palm, Navy Shell. I figured dye color and leather had improved in the last 5 years so I gave it a shot. Bad call... but not even because of the red. Truth is, the Navy faded a bit but in stead of being a deep vibrant blue it just kinda turned a flat worn looking blue. So it faded in that sense, not to a light blue. The red stayed pretty much the same after one season BUT the pocket looks crummy as the ball obviously wears it when being caught. Not a good look as its a greyish color under the dyed layer.
That bring me to my final bit of advice. These colors wear poorly. Fading aside, ANY little blemish such as when you dive for a ball and drag you glove across the dirt and it gets a little scrape.. that scrape POPS!!!! It just blends in on a tan or even to a lesser extent black. I get gloves are meant to be used and scrapes and wear happen as thats natural. I'd guess that because just the top on the leather is dyed, if its a deep enough scrape to get to the grey underneath it stands out because its more contrasting than a black or tan? no clue why, but the colored gloves even LOOK more used than they really are and its prob due to the afore mentioned reasons.
Good luck!