I've tested out quite a few fielders masks, trying to find one I was comfortable enough with to actually use on the field. All of the plastic ones I tried, including Combat's FaceOff (which is widely considered the best plastic one) were just too noticeable and distracting. The wire framed ones were easier for me to play with, and maintained adequate vision. The Rip-it seemed to be the standard, so I started there. It was good, but the chin pad comes off and thats a little annoying. The Schutt mask felt more comfortable, and the chin pad seems to be attached better. Its the first mask that I've been really comfortable wearing, to the point that I don't think it negatively impacted my defense. I almost bought the titanium model for the weight advantage, but after trying on the standard one I didn't think it needed to be any lighter. Its barely noticeable. Just my $.02