Pick one keeper

[jayb-223]

Head to head points league
No penalty for strike outs
No penalty for walks
No points for quality starts - 10pts for wins

C,1b,2b,3b,CI,MI,3 OF,DH,4SP,and 1RP

3rd round Bautista
5th round Donaldson
6th round Rizzo
11th round Cueto

 

[T.Heck]

Wow, Real question is Cueto or Rizzo..... I think I take Rizzo

 

[Sully-7]

Rizzo is the pick if u can keep him multiple years

 

[jayb-223]

It is only for one year. I am leaning Rizzo as well. Donaldson is looking pretty good though. Moving to a hitters park and 3b being a more shallow position than 1b. I have the first pick and am planning on taking Goldy. Trout and Miggy have already been selected as keepers.

 

[T.Heck]

Who is the top 5 hitters you are picking from?

 

[Sully-7]

oh if ur taking Goldy then don't keep Rizzo... I didn't know that info... id keep Bautista - he is a end of the 1st round value and you get him for a 3rd rounder...pairing goldy and bautista is a nice pairing

 

[jayb-223]

According to our scoring system these are the top available hitters
1 Goldschmidt
2 Stanton
3 McCutchen - other teams possible keeper
4 Donaldson
4 Rizzo
5 Bautista
I have my doubts about Bautista being able to stay healthy this year. I have a 1b CI and DH roster spots so plenty of room if I start off with two first baseman.

 

[T.Heck]

I like Rizzo Stanton..... But no shame in Goldy!

 

[bobber_1077]

There are several good OF's available...whereas there are only a handful of good 1B and 3B.
I'd take Donaldson in the Jays lineup, and then draft Goldy and lock down your corner IF spots.

Or keep Rizzo, draft Donaldson, lol...

 

[BAplaya11]

if you are comparing Rizzo and donaldson think about this way. According to ESPN Rizzo's average draft position is 14th a solid 2nd rounder, Donaldson's is 30th a late 3rd maybe early 4th rd pick.

Now you get to keep Rizzo for an 11th rd pick and Donaldson for a 5th rd pick. This is a no brainer, Rizzo 9rds higher than his average draft position.

 

[T.Heck]

^ You got it figured out

 

[jayb-223]

Than I glance down the list three spots below Donaldson and I see Cueto who I could get in the 11th. Causing me to rethink them ALL over again! If I could keep Rizzo in the 11th that would make the decision a lot easier.

 

[BAplaya11]

Than I glance down the list three spots below Donaldson and I see Cueto who I could get in the 11th. Causing me to rethink them ALL over again! If I could keep Rizzo in the 11th that would make the decision a lot easier.

You're right I misread the question, I'd still take Rizzo

 

[T.Heck]

Yeah I still take Rizzo also....... I like Stanton over Donaldson though. If McCutchen opens up I'd probably take him.
I like Cueto too but know way I keep him over a first round position player

 

[The Crimedog]

It's hard not to keep Rizzo. I think this is the play. Everyone else you can possibly redraft if the cards fall right.

 

[jayb-223]

Thanks for all the great input guys. I do believe I have settled on Rizzo.