Same here.I actually use both. Two leagues I play in I am one of 2 people who have bats. So I need the roller bag to carry most of my stash. I use my backpack when I don't have to bring the whole collection or when I'm playing baseball.
It's a nice feeling to travel light and if I didn't need to bring 5 bats I'd use the backpack all the time.
Was looking at backpacks myself, only real concern is that I can't get a feel for if they are bulky or not. The fact I have 3 car seats in my vehicle and work stuff in my trunk means I need something that isn't too big. Definately need something more than what I have though.
First, determine what you want the bag to hold.
Bats / Glove(s) / Shoes / Clothes & Misc.:
You're probably looking at a full sized BP in the range of 26x14x12 or bigger. That's going to be pretty bulky but still smaller than a full-sized bat bag.
If you don't need it to carry bats or shoes or a lot of extra stuff, you can get away with smaller. If you don't need wheels, that'll also save you some space. Something in the size range of 20x12x9 or smaller might suit your needs.
I'm less concerned about bulkiness in my car I particular more along the lines of when I pack up the family to go play in tournaments how would it fit next to the twin stroller, clothes bags and etc that comes with having kids.
My needs would be at least 4 bats, a dozen balls, shoes, glove and book.
Right now my current bag is a very old Easton bat bag with no pockets other than the two bat spaces and the large main pocket that fits my extra batting practice metal bats, balls, shoes etc.
My problem with my current bag is it lack of pockets for small personal stuff and no dedicated space for balls which makes putting stuff away after games a hassle.
Though I've contemplated just getting a 5gal bucket for balls
I'm less concerned about bulkiness in my car I particular more along the lines of when I pack up the family to go play in tournaments how would it fit next to the twin stroller, clothes bags and etc that comes with having kids.
If space is tight invest in a hard shell roof top cargo carrier. I got one when I was running out of trunk space when my girls were little.
Pull it out, load up the kids & your stuff & pull away! It sounds like you might be a candidate for an option like this.
I actually have a hitch hauler but every time we take that on trips my wife thinks we can shop since we have space. I'd like to keep that as a last resort ; )
What do you check your bats in when flying with batpacks?If you fly to tourneys roller bags might not last.
2 years in a row we won roller bags.
2 years in a row the bags wheels were broken off by the airline flying to Huntsman tourney.
Bat Packs eliminate that eventuality but rollers are so much easier