Thought on Trade or Counter Offer?

[12345]

A guy in my league wants Marshall and Cameron from me, but I am having a hard time coming up with a good trade. I want a #1 back that is producing this season because as you can see I have 5 starting backs on my team, most of which have greatly underperformed.

Here is my team:
QB Matthew Stafford, Det QB Draft
RB C.J. Spiller, Buf RB Q Draft
RB Lamar Miller, Mia RB Draft
WR Brandon Marshall, Chi WR Draft
WR Reggie Wayne, Ind WR Draft
TE Jordan Cameron, Cle TE Draft
FLEX Heath Miller, Pit TE P Free Agency
FLEX Justin Blackmon, Jac WR Q Free Agency
D/ST Panthers D/ST D/ST Free Agency
K Matt Prater, Den K Draft
Bench Darren McFadden, Oak RB Draft
Bench Cecil Shorts, Jac WR Q Draft
Bench Steve Johnson, Buf WR P Draft
Bench Ben Tate, Hou RB P Draft
Bench Willis McGahee, Cle RB Q Free Agency
Bench Zac Stacy, StL RB P Free Agency


Here is his team:
QB Nick Foles, Phi QB Free Agency
RB Jamaal Charles, KC RB Draft
RB Joseph Randle, Dal RB Free Agency
WR Pierre Garcon, Wsh WR Draft
WR Torrey Smith, Bal WR Draft
TE Jermaine Gresham, Cin TE Free Agency
FLEX Stevan Ridley, NE RB Draft
FLEX Ryan Mathews, SD RB Draft
D/ST Chargers D/ST D/ST Free Agency
K Blair Walsh, Min K Q Draft
Bench Maurice Jones-Drew, Jac RB P Draft
Bench Anquan Boldin, SF WR Draft
Bench Le'Veon Bell, Pit RB Draft
Bench Bengals D/ST D/ST Draft
Bench Terrelle Pryor, Oak QB Free Agency
Bench Kris Durham, Det WR Free Agency


We are both sitting at 3-3. He has offered:

Charles and Smith -> Cameron, Marshall, & DMC

Do I go with what was offered or can you think of something that I might counter with. I feel like I need a top back to get me over the final hump. I am sitting in first in my division (4 divisions of 3 teams) and Each division winner makes playoff and 2 next highest seeds are wild card. I think my current team gets me in the playoffs, but not sure where it takes me when I get there.

I don't feel as great with Cameron with Weeden under center and feel Miller will get me only a few points less than Cameron.

 

[Primo]

See if he'll throw in durnham as well but ya, id do that

 

[T.Heck]

Damn..... thats tough. I just turned down a tough one today, Its hard to trade sometimes when its square.

But anyways I wouldnt mind playing Miller at te and it be awesome to have Charles, Your short on WR and cant really count Stevie and thats from a Bills fan lol

I been trying to move Mcfad, If I get anything of value he is gone.

 

[NDshotokan]

I would trade just about anything for JC in a PPR league. He's the focal point of that offense and can bust one on any play.

I'd take the trade offered.

 

[G Rat]

Go for it. But good luck with TE.

 

[NDshotokan]

Meh. I'd stream TE's. Reed, Graham, Wright, etc. Plenty of young up and coming talent.

 

[12345]

I made the trade and got Dunham as well.

 

[stork]

Good trade.

 

[12345]

Damn..... thats tough. I just turned down a tough one today, Its hard to trade sometimes when its square.

But anyways I wouldnt mind playing Miller at te and it be awesome to have Charles, Your short on WR and cant really count Stevie and thats from a Bills fan lol

I been trying to move Mcfad, If I get anything of value he is gone.

Back up top!


And now I am even shorter with Wayne gone for the season lol.

I am 2 on the waiver priority, so do I pick up Mike James (Doug Martin's replacement) and use him or another back as trade bait to get a WR or do I pick up Boykins from Green Bay with my waiver. I highly doubt I would get both.

 

[Flyman]

I made the trade and got Dunham as well.

That's a really good deal for you. Durham is the clear WR2 in Detroit now, and he should be fairly productive. Gives you some very good depth.