On-base % should be higher than batting average in most cases unless the guy never walks and hits a lot of sac flies.
In softball OBP is the best indicator IMHO.....
I had guys on the team that hit .700/.800 for a tourney, but for the entire season the team leader was .587 BA/ .593 OBP. That was over 62 games, 184 ABs, 199 PAs.
I agree completely, and for the record, I don't know that I'd have beaten that guy in OBP. I just walk more than the average softball player and want credit for it.