So is Eli > Peyton?

hbwb

~~~~~~~~~~~~
you're right...and in related, theorhetical news, if the 2000 ravens defense and the 07 pats offense comnbined, they'd be the best ever.....

wtf is your piont?? you can mix and match a make great teams??? congrats

No I'm saying they belong with those teams mentioned by you as is. And with a better qb there would be little argument except from people who just like to argue.
 

hbwb

~~~~~~~~~~~~
Manning revolutionalized the game......he threw passes into windows no one had thought of trying before and he did it every single time out. The reason you see Rodgers and Brady and Brees thread the needle is because Peyton showed them it was possible. Before, if you only had a 2 sq foot area, you threw it elsewhere......Manning just threw it in the 2 sq ft.....couple that w/ no longer being able to paly physical in teh secondary and it's why the NFL is an arena league

I have seen a few qb's before manning thread the needle. He was more consistent but there have been several who were good at hitting their 'covered' guys.
 

freak98guy

Place Clever Title Here
Yes cuz all that matters is which guy has more rings... It has nothing to do with the other guys on his team :rolleyes:
 
Top