Paulypal
Addicted to Softballfans
Those balls you're using would kill any performance a fancy bat may have, just nothing there with a clincher other than bat weight vs ball weight, rather use a woody and 52cor ball.
Despite what you hear people say there is a difference in bat performance. For instance I believe that the newer ASA bats perform better because they are made for .52. Now the SB12 and Clincher Gold are not .52's but they come off the bat faster with the newer bats.
Also another thing to consider is the pitch speed when you talking about bat durability. You dont have to worry much with the Clinchers but I have seen the SB12 destroy many bats in the cooler weather due to faster pitch speed.
Also - if you think shaving bats is only a slo-pitch issue....it isnt. The problem with modified is that your pitching from 46 feet away and you have no time and no where to go. Makes it a little scary.
Another facet of the game is that we USE TO play 9 man modified with bunting and stealing. That was much more like baseball. Playing third and playing in for the bunt - you had to have some serious trust that your pitcher wasnt going to lay over a cookie for the batter. You also needed an excellent catcher.