I ran into something similar but on my league's facebook. Guy says "power hitter with great defense looking for a new team". Arranged to call him up, dude says he was the leading homerun hitter in another league and he was an all star hardball player etc, that whole bit. Bring the guy out, he hits like garbage, boots everything that comes anywhere near him in the field at every position I tried him at. Guys like this also have an excuse list 5 miles long, the best one was... "man, these bats are garbage, I cant hit with em, get me an Easton redline, Ill go deep every at bat" (he tried a worth 454, an SSR2 and others).