I would much rather play in shorts but the shin guards kinda defeated the purpose and I think it made me more of a target. Don't know that I really care anymore and shorts would make my current guards real easy to take off.
If I'm playing against the 52s I'm probably going to skip the shinguards. I just don't want a broken leg. I skated and played soccer growing up so I can handle the pain. I got the BMX style with velcro straps so I can always add them at any point.
I always consider myself a target. I never talk trash, but make fun of myself and the dumber guys on the other team somehow think I'm mocking them.